“With an entrance as epic as the Heathers’ reputation, the audience expects big things, and boy, do the Heathers not disappoint. Katie McQuail (Heather Chandler), Olivia Manlove (Heather Duke) and Makayla Weselinski (Heather McNamara) fit so perfectly together as the trendy trio. Their characterizations are on point, their dynamic is dynamite, and their song “Candy Store” is a highlight of the show.” - Amber Kusching, South Jersey Critics, 2024